Hey Adam,
ITM
I just finished listening to episode 1761 and I wanted to
fill you in on the India Pakistan situation and why I believe that this
is something that will not be resolved in our Lifetime. Both countries
since creation by the British which led to
about 2 million dead with some of the most unspeakable human on human
violence known to mankind have been fighting over this land.
The British when they leave do leave a trail of blood and
Horror something similar to the Israel conflict where they promised the
land to the Turks, the Iranians, the Arabs and the Jews (a fascinating
podcast I can recommend on this subject here https://youtu.be/2vsX4iQouOc?si=BIBHRl-UV8W9UTFX)
. The principle of partition was: for the British terrirories, the
Hindu majority part became India and the Muslim majority became
Pakistan. The vassal kings in India were given a choice to choose who
they wanted to join. The Hindu king of Kashmir decided
at the very last moment to join India, though through demographic
change Kashmir had become muslim majority (Deja vu Europe?). Pakistan
didnt like this and launched an invasion to occupy 1/3 of Kashmir parts
of which they gave China after China erased Tibet
off the map. Its very sensitive for Pakistan for their identity as
Pakistan stands for Panjab Afghan Kashmir Indus - Stan (land of those
people).
For the Hindu Indians, Kashmir is a very holy place, all
the Hindu gods are believed to live in the Himalayas. The abrhamic
religions like Islam and christianity had a problem with this and
Churchill didnt like the Hindus and their religion he
is also quoted as saying "Indians are a beastly people with a beastly
religion”. Several bible followers today even curse the Indians as the
devil worshippers and would like to see us killed unfortunately.
When the country split, even though India was bigger,
Pakistan got the larger military assets and the army as lot of. the
peoples of the Pakistan region were warriors and mercenaries. India
though went through the cycle of socialism and glimpses
of capitalism though focussing on development
The two countries have fought several wars 3 major (I have
family members who were injured in one of them) and though India has
had the upper hand, the Pakistanis seem to always claim victory.
The other aspect of all this is how the politicians on
both sides have weaponised this to play a psyop on the people to get
them to sacrifice and spend unbelievable amounts on weapon and armed
forces. The Indian side goes hey look we are so much
better than Pakistan, which though true is a bit low bar. The
politicians use the outsider Pakistan to get their agendas. Across the
border in Pakistan its treated as a holy war and a duty to destroy the
Idol worshippers and non believers. Given their strategic
location (bordering Iran which is a Shia enemy for Pakistan,
Afghanistan and China) Pakistan was the convenient ally for the west for
their dirty work and now for China to tackle India and the west.
Therefore Pakistan always got backing from the west in terms
of Military tech and weapons which enabled the bankrupt country to wage
a war through all means.
The worst part of all this is that for Pakistan Kashmir is
only a frontier to conquer and break up India. For India the fear is
that if Pakistan takes Kashmir, the Indian muslims will chose religion
over country and it will be over for the Hindus
Hope this gives some neutral context though I have skin in the game on the Indian side
Regards
Kedar